Jason Deamer

President | NMLS: 144600

Should You Pay Points for a Lower Mortgage Rate in Utah?

A lower mortgage rate can come with a higher upfront cost. Here’s how to decide whether that tradeoff fits your budget and plans.

A lower mortgage rate can look like the obvious choice. But if getting that rate requires paying more at closing, the better option depends on how long you expect to keep the loan and how much cash you want to preserve.

Whether you’re buying a home or refinancing anywhere in Utah, compare the upfront cost with the monthly savings before choosing.

What are mortgage points?

Discount points are an upfront charge paid in exchange for a lower interest rate than you would otherwise receive. One point equals 1% of the loan amount.

That does not mean one point reduces your interest rate by one percentage point. The rate reduction varies with the lender, loan and market conditions.

Ask for the actual dollar cost and payment difference. A points percentage by itself doesn’t tell you whether the offer is worthwhile.

Start with a simple break-even calculation

Suppose one mortgage option costs $3,000 more upfront and saves $75 per month compared with another option.

Divide the extra cost by the monthly savings:

$3,000 ÷ $75 = 40 months

In this hypothetical example, it takes about three years and four months for the payment savings to recover the additional upfront cost.

If you pay off or refinance the loan after two years, you would have received $1,800 in payment savings against the $3,000 extra cost. If you keep it for five years, the savings would total $4,500.

This is a starting point, not a complete cost analysis. It doesn’t account for differences in remaining loan balances, the value of keeping your cash available, or interest charged on costs financed into the mortgage.

Think about how long you’ll keep the mortgage

The relevant timeline is how long you expect to keep this loan, which may be shorter than how long you’ll own the home.

Paying points may deserve a closer look when you expect to keep the mortgage beyond the break-even period and still have comfortable savings after closing.

A lower upfront cost may be more attractive when you expect to sell sooner, want to preserve cash, or aren’t confident you’ll keep the loan long enough to recover the cost.

Avoid building the decision around a promised future refinance. Rates, your finances and your home’s value can change. Choose a mortgage that works with your circumstances today.

Ask about lender credits, too

Lender credits can provide another tradeoff. You may accept a higher interest rate in exchange for a credit toward closing costs.

That can reduce the cash you need upfront, but the higher rate can increase your borrowing cost over time. Compare the credit with the additional payment over your expected timeline.

Also, a loan with no discount points can still have other closing costs. Ask for the complete breakdown.

Compare the same loan assumptions

Before comparing two offers, confirm that they use the same loan amount, program, term and rate-lock period. Check whether both rates are locked and whether mortgage insurance is included where applicable.

Then compare:

  • Discount points and other lender charges.
  • Lender credits.
  • Principal and interest payments.
  • Mortgage insurance, if applicable.
  • Total cash needed at closing.

Different estimates for taxes or insurance can make one payment appear lower without improving the financing itself. Keep those assumptions consistent.

For a purchase, consider how closing expenses affect your available savings. For a refinance, also check whether costs are being added to the loan balance.

Get a comparison built around your plans

The lowest rate deserves a look, but it needs to earn back its additional cost.

Salt City Home Loans, LLC helps borrowers throughout Utah compare mortgage options from multiple lenders. Jason Deamer has worked in mortgage origination since 2001 and can help you understand the tradeoffs between upfront costs, payments and your expected timeline.

Explore our home purchase options or refinance options, or call 801-308-9228 to discuss your goals. Reach Jason directly at 801-528-9204.

Salt City Home Loans, LLC. Company NMLS 1784194. Jason Deamer, NMLS 144600. Serving Utah. Examples are illustrative and are not loan offers. Loan approval and terms depend on borrower qualifications and lender requirements.

Let us help you!

Our representative will be in touch with you.

* Specific loan program availability and requirements may vary. Please get in touch with your mortgage advisor for more information.